Free 3-Part Webinar Series: How to Scale Your ABA Practice, with Boost CEO Lani Fritts. Free 3-Part Series, starts Dec 3: How to Scale Your ABA Practice. Starts Thu Dec 3 · 1:00 PM ET Save your free seat
top of page

Coordination of Benefits in ABA: How to Bill Secondary Insurance and Get Paid

Nov 11
9 min read

by Emily Roche and Tori Bejar


Quick Answer

Coordination of benefits (COB) is the set of rules that decides which health plan pays first when a client has more than one. For ABA practices, getting the order right matters on every claim: bill the primary plan first, wait for its payment or denial, then send the secondary claim with the primary's payment details attached. Secondary coverage has become more common as more state Medicaid programs cover ABA therapy.


ABA billing specialist comparing a primary and a secondary insurance card before submitting a claim

Key Takeaways

  • When a client has two commercial plans, the plan that covers them as the policyholder is usually primary, and the plan that covers them as a dependent is secondary. Medicaid works differently: a child is often the Medicaid policyholder, but Medicaid still pays last, so a parent's commercial plan that covers the child as a dependent comes first.

  • For children covered by two parents, most plans follow the birthday rule: the parent whose birthday comes first in the calendar year has the primary plan.

  • Medicaid is the payer of last resort, so every other source of coverage gets billed before it (including Tricare).

  • A secondary claim needs the primary payer's paid amount and adjustment reasons, or it will come back asking for more information or denied.

  • Most coordination of benefits denials start at intake, when other coverage was never captured or the order was set wrong.


Many ABA clients carry two plans. A child may be covered by both parents' employer plans or by a commercial plan with Medicaid behind it. Each extra plan can protect your revenue, but only if your team bills them in the right order and sends each payer what it needs. When that breaks down, claims bounce between payers while the therapy you delivered sits unpaid.


What is coordination of benefits in ABA billing?


Coordination of benefits is how health plans decide who pays first, second and, occasionally, third when a person has multiple insurance policies. The primary plan processes the claim as if no other coverage existed. The secondary plan then looks at what the primary paid and considers the remaining balance under its own rules.


For an ABA practice, COB touches the whole revenue cycle. It starts when intake records every plan a client has, carries through to authorizations for each policy, and ends with how billing builds and sequences each claim.


How much will the secondary policy actually pay?


It is important to understand how a secondary plan calculates what it will pay on each claim. The secondary plan will only pay up to its own allowed reimbursement rate. For example, a child has a primary commercial plan that allows $70 per hour for RBT therapy. The primary pays $50 and a $20 copay remains after the primary processes.

·       The child also has Medicaid, and the Medicaid rate in your state is $50 per hour.

·       When you bill the claim to the secondary Medicaid policy, the claim will process with $0 allowed and no further payment will be made. This happens when the primary payer already paid as much or more than the secondary payer allows for that service.

·       If the secondary payer is Medicaid, you cannot bill the client/family for the outstanding amount that is left in your billing system.

·       If the secondary payer is a commercial policy, you can bill the client/family if the secondary payer shows patient responsibility after processing the claim. You can only bill for remaining patient responsibility and not any more.


How do you know which plan is primary?


Most commercial plans follow order-of-benefits rules based on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) model, which many states have adopted. State law and individual plan terms can vary, so treat these as the common pattern and confirm with each payer:


  • Medicaid is the payer of last resort.

  • Employee before dependent. A plan that covers the person as an employee or subscriber pays before a plan that covers them as a dependent. Therefore, a child with a “child-only” plan where they are the subscriber and only covered individual must consider that plan as primary over a plan where they are the dependent under a parent’s policy.

  • The birthday rule for children. When both parents cover a child, the plan of the parent whose birthday (month and day, not year) comes first in the calendar year is usually primary.

  • Court orders and custody. For children of separated or divorced parents, a court decree that assigns health coverage will override general rules.

  • Longer coverage as a tiebreaker. When no other rule settles it, the plan that has covered the person longer is often primary.


Plans also send COB questionnaires to members. Members are required to report additional insurance policies to each of their covered plans. If this has been done, then the insurance company should also be able to confirm which plan is primary when you call for eligibility verifications. If a family ignores the COB questionnaire, the payer may hold or deny claims until it is answered, which is why your intake team should ask families about secondary coverage policies from the beginning.


Why is Medicaid always billed last?


Federal law makes Medicaid the payer of last resort. Any other coverage a client has, including a parent's employer plan, must be billed first. Medicaid then considers what is left, up to its own allowed amount. State Medicaid programs and their managed care plans call this third party liability (TPL), and they keep their own records of other coverage.


For ABA, this matters because many children qualify for Medicaid in addition to a parent's commercial plan. If the commercial plan covers ABA, it pays first. If it denies the service as not covered, Medicaid typically wants that denial on file before it will pay. And, certain denial reasons will not be accepted for payment by the secondary plan. For example, most secondary plans will not pick up payment if the denial reason from the primary is failure by the provider to obtain authorization for services. Each state sets its own rules for how to submit that proof, so check your state Medicaid provider manual and your managed care contracts.


What does a secondary claim need to get paid?


A secondary claim is not a copy of the primary claim. The secondary payer needs to see what already happened. On an electronic claim, that means:

  • The amount the primary paid, at the claim or line level.

  • The adjustment reason codes from the primary's remittance, showing why any amount was not paid (for example, deductible, coinsurance or a contractual write-off).

  • The date the primary processed the claim.


Some payers still ask for a copy of the primary explanation of benefits (EOB) with paper claims or appeals. Either way, the codes and amounts must match the primary's remittance exactly. A secondary claim sent before the primary has processed, or without its payment details, is one of the fastest ways to earn a denial.


What should you do when the primary plan denies the claim?


Read the denial reason before sending anything to the secondary payer. The right next step depends on why the primary said no:

  • Fixable errors. If the primary denied for a billing problem, such as a missing modifier, a credentialing issue or a lapsed authorization, correct it and resubmit to the primary. The secondary payer will usually deny too if the primary's denial was avoidable.

  • Service not covered. If the primary plan does not cover the service, send the secondary claim with the primary's denial details attached. This is the common path when Medicaid sits behind a plan that excludes ABA.

  • Benefits exhausted. If the client hit a visit or dollar limit on the primary plan, document that and bill the secondary with the remittance showing the limit.


Track these by payer. A pattern of avoidable primary denials points to an upstream problem, and our guide to ABA denial management covers how to fix the cause instead of the symptom


How do timely filing limits work for secondary claims?


Every payer sets a deadline for receiving claims, and secondary payers are no exception. Most measure the secondary deadline from the date the primary processed the claim rather than the date of service, but the window and the starting point vary by payer and by state Medicaid program. Waiting weeks for a primary remittance can quietly eat into that window.


Two habits protect you. First, keep a list of each payer's secondary filing limit where your billing team can see it. Second, have workflows that allow you to consistently identify outstanding revenue that needs to be billed to a secondary payer. This can be difficult to identify in some billing systems, and you should work with your biller to create effective processes. For secondary plans whose timely filing deadlines are based on service date rather than the primary EOB date, you may need to bill the secondary claim before the primary has finished adjudicating the claim in order to keep the billing window open. You can always go back and submit a corrected secondary claim if primary processes for additional payment.


What are the most common coordination of benefits denials?


  • Other coverage on file. The payer believes another plan is primary, often shown as claim adjustment reason code 22 (this care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits).

  • Missing primary payment information. The secondary claim arrived without the primary's paid amount or adjustment codes.

  • Wrong order. The practice billed the secondary plan as primary or billed Medicaid before a commercial plan.

  • Outdated COB records. The family changed jobs or plans, and the payer's records no longer match what the client actually has.

  • Unanswered COB questionnaire. The payer is waiting on the family to confirm other coverage.

  • Timely filing. Some payers are not great at processing secondary claims and will often quickly deny for timely filing based on the original date of services. Be sure your billing team is ready to follow up on claims that need to be reprocessed due to incorrect denials. If this denial is a consistent pattern, you should reach out to the payer to better understand how they want information from the primary payer submitted, and you may be able to adjust billing submissions to prevent more denials.


Each of these is cheaper to prevent than to appeal. They are also a big reason COB problems drag down your clean claim rate.


How do you prevent COB problems before they start?


  • Ask about every plan at intake. Ask families directly whether the client is covered by both parents, a stepparent, Medicaid or any other plan, and capture front and back of each card. Make the question on your intake documents required to answer whether or not a secondary policy is active.  

  • Verify eligibility on every plan. Run benefits checks with each payer, not just the one the family mentioned first. 

  • Set the order once, then recheck it. Record which plan is primary and why, reverify at each authorization renewal and at the start of the plan year. 

  • Get authorizations for each payer. 

  • Tie billing to the record. Claims should pull the payer order from the client record automatically, so nobody has to remember it.


How does Boost handle clients with more than one plan?


Boost is the ABA Practice Intelligence Platform with Revenue Cycle Management Services. Coverage details captured at intake carry through to authorizations, scheduling and billing, so the payer order on a claim comes from the client record instead of someone's memory. Our billing team, made up of operators who have run ABA practices, works primary and secondary claims as part of the same revenue cycle, so a client with two plans does not become a stack of aging claims.


Frequently asked questions about coordination of benefits in ABA


What is coordination of benefits?

Coordination of benefits is the set of rules health plans use to decide which plan pays first when a person has more than one. The primary plan pays as if it were the only coverage. The secondary plan then reviews what the primary paid and may cover some or all of the remaining balance under its own terms.


How does the birthday rule work for a child covered by two parents?

Under the birthday rule, the plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year is usually primary for the child. Only the month and day count, not the year of birth. Court orders, custody arrangements and state law can change the order, so confirm with each payer during intake.


Is Medicaid primary or secondary for ABA services?

Medicaid is always billed last because federal law makes it the payer of last resort. If a client has a commercial plan, that plan is billed first. Medicaid then considers the remaining balance, or pays when the primary plan denies the service as not covered and the practice can show that denial.


What do you need to send with a secondary claim?

A secondary claim needs the primary payer's information, the amount the primary paid, and the adjustment reason codes from its remittance explaining any unpaid amount. Some payers also want a copy of the primary explanation of benefits. Missing or mismatched primary details are among the most common reasons secondary claims are denied.


What does denial code 22 mean?

Claim adjustment reason code 22 means the payer believes the care may be covered by another payer under coordination of benefits. It usually signals that the payer has other coverage on file as primary. Check the client's coverage, confirm the correct order with the family and both plans, and rebill in the right sequence.


How long do you have to file a secondary claim?

It depends on the payer. Many secondary payers measure their filing limit from the date the primary plan processed the claim. Keep each payer's secondary deadline on file and work secondary claims as soon as the primary remittance posts so you do not run out of time.


Focus on clients, not clerical work.

Clients with two plans should mean more protection for your revenue, not more paperwork. If your team is chasing secondary claims or COB denials, we will walk through how Boost carries coverage from intake to the claim, using your own payer mix.


Book a walkthrough at boostresults.com.


This article is for informational purposes and does not constitute billing, legal, or financial advice. Payer rules and requirements vary; confirm specifics with your payers.

bottom of page